The 10 most offensively annoying “New Rock” bands of the past decade

This past decade, whatever it ends up being called –my vote is for “the oughts”–has been marked by the continual decline of mainstream rock music.

Despite this, I often get frustrated when people tell me that music “sucks” now. There are thousands of good bands still making music in the spirit of creativity and innovation that is evident when listening to music from, say, the classic rock era.

However, in the modern media environment, exposure to the masses through mainstream formats takes a very specific, specialized sound. At the same time, that mass of people—the mainstream—has increasingly fragmented with the rise of alternative mediums like satellite radio, and most obviously, the internet.

The effect of this is that it becomes increasingly difficult for talented bands to force their way into mainstream exposure without significantly changing their sound.

In Toronto for example, The Edge wouldn’t touch Kings of Leon until they decided to sound less like themselves, and a lot more like The Killers (Can’t you just hear Brandon Flowers belting out the “Someone like you” line in the Kings’ “Use Somebody”, complete with half-megaphone effect?).

The truly great bands of the modern era—Pearl Jam, The Tragically Hip, Wilco—are holdovers from a prior generation, still pounding pavement and continually finding massive, dedicated fan bases largely through their reputation for electrifying live performances.

The problem that faces many of the best, younger bands I’ve heard over the past decade is that radio, at least in Canada, has little-to-no interest in supporting them. So what we’re left with is a few great bands, and many potentially great bands squandered because of a lack of exposure.

Granted, radio exposure, in the grand scheme of things, is much less important than in years gone by. Who listens to the radio anymore?

Unforunately, I still do. Quite frequently. And so fair reader, as the decade draws to the close, I feel it is time to give some of these popular mainstream rock acts some recognition. Lads, you’ve cluttered up my airwaves for too long; this is the least I can do to pay you back. Without further adieu, here are…

…The 10 most offensively annoying “New Rock” bands of the past decade:

10. Theory of a Deadman

Question: What kind of sound do you get when you’re a ripoff of a band that sets the standard for generic rock? The answer is this Delta, BC quartet, which burst on to the scene in 2002. Their first single was called “Ain’t No Surprise”, which is kind of appropriate, because it ain’t no surprise that they find themselves on this list.

Now, I don’t want to spoil the rest of the list, so let’s just say that their music is heavily reminiscent of the man that signed them, and produces their records.

One might even feel like they want some amount of money returned to them for whoever is shelling out to make Theory of a Deadman albums.

That joke might even make sense by the end of this list.

9. Hedley

Now that's what I call rock & roll.

Rising to fame through Canadian Idol—yes, really—Hedley’s brand of teen-bop-punk-pop is not only amazingly terrible, it’s amazingly stale. Hedley would have fit right in with some of the other bands that will populate this list, but most of them have fallen by the wayside.

Thank goodness that we have Hedley to carry the torch in to the next decade.

And (negative) bonus points to Hedley for shooting a video at my community grocery store. The place has stunk of emo ever since.

8. Blink 182

Most people would tell you that when they were coming up, Blink was a good little punk band. By the time 2000 rolled around they had sold around 20 million records and their sound had shifted firmly to the mainstream.

My main problem with Blink was their attitudes. Is there a less funny band that apparently considers themselves to be hilarious?

Well, at some point the band themselves realized that they’re not really that funny and tried to make a serious album. And it was serious, alright: Seriously boring.

On the plus side, their song “Feelin’ This” spawned a running joke that lasted for years with my friends in high school. So props to them on writing that one.

Perhaps the worst thing about Blink 182 was all the bands that they inspired, such as…

7. Simple Plan

…Blink’s poser Canadian little brothers. Although these guys were eventually shuttered off to adult contemporary/hot hits stations, they hit it big riding the pop/punk wave established by their “big brothers” Blink.

To call them punk would be an outright travesty though. Simple Plan were a little more Smash Mouth than they were Black Flag. Most of all, they were just annoying.

Probably the most memorable thing about them was that their guitarist span around in circles really fast. Yep, some legacy there boys.

6. Fallout Boy

When I was a kid, little girls listened to the Backstreet Boys and *NSYNC. Even lesser known boy bands with terribly dumb names like 98 Degrees, b44, and (I refuse to look up the proper syntax for those names–*NYSNC is more than enough). Now, apparently they listen to this garbage.

Bring back the boy bands! At least they were upfront about how manufactured they were. And nobody ever says I look like Nick Carter anymore. I think a part of me misses that.

5. Panic at the Disco

Take the theatrics of Queen, strip them of their coolness and mix with what sound like rejected Fall Out Boy tracks—It’s these guys! Thankfully they’ve never really broken through on the radio stations I listen to, but they were pretty unavoidable for a while there.

It’s funny these guys are called Panic at the Disco. I know that if I were at a disco and one of their songs came on, I would panic. Then I would start getting belligerent, freak out and accidently elbow some meathead. Then the meathead would probably turn and beat me up.

So go away, Panic at the Disco.  In addition to being awful, you could potentially get me beat up.

4. Good Charlotte

They sound even worse than they look.

It wouldn’t be proper to rag on the prior bands without mentioning the one that lay the foundation for them.

Good Charlotte is perhaps the single worst band on this list. Fortunately, they were so popular that they seem to have grown bored with music, or at least satisfied enough with their earnings to go away. I haven’t heard about them in years now.

I guess they’ve gone from complaining about “Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous” to living that same

life—which is fine, if it gets them off my television set.

But it’s still not enough to make me forget how pervasive they were at one point, pumping out anti-authority pop anthems that suburban middle-class white kids could believe in. Fight the power, kiddos.

Most importantly, if you’re going to put “Good” in your band’s name, you better be…well, good.

Otherwise, you’re just making it too easy on snarky journalists to rip you. Like so:

Good Charlotte?

More like “Fourth Most Offensively Annoying Band of the Decade Charlotte”.

3. Green Day

Green Day has managed to pull off quite the feat during the past decade, in that they’ve won over a completely new fan base while their old fan base has completely soured on them.

Where did it all go wrong (from a creative perspective) or right (from a financial perspective)?

Well, in 2004, America was a nation of unrest. As public sentiment turned further against the President, angry 12-year-olds everywhere were looking for an outlet to vent their political frustrations. They found it in American Idiot.

If you listen closely to that album, you can actually hear them selling out.

Suddenly, a band whose bread and butter were three minute songs about the perils of teendom became political crusaders.

It was never an easy fit, but radio didn’t seem to mind—they absolutely killed whatever quality the album had to it, playing single after single until the old lady down the street knew the words to “Boulevard of Broken Dreams”.

2. Linkin Park

These guys win the award for band most pushed by new rock radio for no discernable reason. I mean, obviously they have their fans, but don’t count this blog among them. This blog will be insulted if you do.

Linkin Park were the epitome of the Rap/Rock fad that ruled new rock radio for a time earlier this decade. But they weren’t a particularly good hard rock band. And they certainly weren’t good rappers.

It took an actual rapper, Jay-Z, to pull any redeeming quality out of their music.

I wrote this passage in past tense because Linkin Park seems to have dropped off the face of the earth lately. Are they still around, or have I just blocked them out?

And seriously, what was with the guitar player wearing those headphones? Was he just listening to Zeppelin or something better than Linkin Park?

1. Nickelback

Well, at least they have that snazzy brown leather jacket.

The 80s had Bon Jovi; The 90s had Matchbox 20. This decade’s most offensively annoying band combined the arena rock sensibilities of the former with the radio-friendliness of the latter. Yes, you got it; the most ridiculously popular, offensively annoying band of the past decade has to be Nickelback.

Coming out of Hannah, Alberta, Nickelback struggled for a while to get some mainstream exposure. They solved their problem in 2001, with the release of the single “How You Remind Me”—literally, the most played song in modern radio HISTORY.

(To be fair, everyone liked, or at least didn’t mind that song the first time they heard it. You can admit it…But I choose not to. Everyone except for me).

Several popular singles followed off that album, Silver Side Up, each sounding much like the last. Nickelback became a veritable sales juggernaut during the past decade. Subsequent singles earned the band praise like “undoubtedly the worst song of their career…maybe all time”.

Which just proves the old adage to be true: the masses are asses.

Nickelback’s awfulness probably peaked with the release of “Photograph”. The song itself was generic and bad enough, but the video pushed it to another level with off-the-charts unintentional comedy.

Perhaps the only redeeming factor about Nickelback is that they’re huge in the States. So at least us Canucks aren’t the only poor souls subjected to their dreck.

I bet that it’s almost enough to make America reconsider free trade.



Filed under Editorial, Lists

9 responses to “The 10 most offensively annoying “New Rock” bands of the past decade

  1. Ed

    Pearl Jam, a truly great band of the past decade? I used to like them when I was young and naive. The “higher social calling” and manufactured angst of Mr Vedder finally took it’s toll on me. I call Eddie a perpetrator. He’s full of shit and had everyone fooled.

  2. i very enjoy all your writing way, very interesting,
    don’t quit and keep penning mainly because it just worth to look through it.
    looking forward to read much of your own well written articles, have a good one!

  3. Nikki

    Though I don’t agree with your Kings of Leon/Killers comparison (the two bands are both immensely talented but are vastly different from one another, in my opinion), I’d have to say this list is damn accurate.
    I can’t tell you how many dirty looks I’ve accumulated over the years for all the times I’ve simply stated the truth…Nickleback is terrible.
    Overall–my sentiments exactly, and I loved this article.

  4. Will

    Well, I do agree with almost all of these bands that you have posted up (besides Blink) However, i do find that I run into more and more people like you who insist constantly on voicing their negative opinion about bands. Is there really a point in critiquing all of these mainstream bands? We all know that most of them were, or just recently became corporate sellouts and it even shows that you possess your own Naivety by writing this article. Their is an already underlying consciousness among listeners of music that this type of music is “annoying” and “tasteless”, and it really is insensible to try and convince others that their taste in music is “wrong”.
    In regards to Blink 182, they were the only band that I connected with in my youth that were formed while I was in my teens. I used to listen only to Nirvana, Muddy Waters and Pink Floyd. I know you may consider those artists to be greatly different from Blink, but I found the same natural ability to create music that pragmatically evolved within a generation. Songs that battled corporate money machines (Backstreet Boys, Spice Girls) and offered a different, more musically inclined group of listeners. I can understand if you dont accept their humour in some of their songs, however, I hope you can see the value in at least some of their songs, if you dont I think you still owe them some respect for distracting you from Brittney Spears.


  5. i'm not giving you my name and the email address is fake ;) have a nice day

    green day? sell outs ? They were annoyed by George bush as well that’s why they wrote it and in this era of music people want quick singles that are easy to pick out of an album, not 9 minute long multi-sectional songs on a concept album ! That’s the most punk they’ve ever been.

  6. This list is great, I dont disagree with anything here and actually laughed at a few of the write ups. If only the list could have been a bit bigger so that you could have thrown in a few of those anthem’esq bands with their metrosexual typical guy voices and flamer haircuts who try to belt out the sorta shit you hear on a sports commercial. or then theres the hipsters, vampire weekend and shit like that.. a-holes wearing cardigans and my sisters jeans, and or fedora hats.. just so you KNOW they are musicians. fedora hats are annoying enough on their own to qualify any wearer for a top X list. and to the dude above, Green Day DID sell out. they were cool in the early to mid 90’s, and slowly drifted. I have their albums, i’m no off-the-bat hater, but what they are making these days, american idiot onwards… it’s designed for teeny-boppers and people going through “phases”. theres no quality beyond that. “i’m annoyed at the world so i’m gonna say you’re stupid”, it’s perfect for outspoken loud-mouth teenage girls lookin for a scene and think they are entitled to be pushed through life on a recliner. i’ll just be clear on that… Green Day ‘were’ pretty good once upon a time.

  7. Jim

    I don’t agree with you with about half of the bands you posted. However, I do respect you for the way you point out what you don’t like about a band. Most people just say they hate a band and it ends there.

  8. Jason

    Im not a fan of any of those bands but i like most of them. I listen to older or underground music like Shadow Gallery.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s